Tip closest to residents to remain untouched
Tip closest to residents to remain untouched
Clearing up the confusion
This information seeks to clarify which tips are included in ERI Ltd's proposal to mine and then flatten certain coal tips in Caerphilly. The tips selected appear to be on the basis of which would be most profitable to mine of the 'waste coal' they contain, rather than which most endanger residents. This is not surprising as the proposal is being brought by a for-profit mining company, but it does differ from how the company is presenting itself as an expert in remediation rather than mining.
Tip closest to Trethomas residents would remain untouched
Tip 90319 that most concerns residents is closest to them - it backs onto the gardens of some residents. It's also a site with concerns surrounding possibly toxic elements contained within the tip. Due to its proximity to residents, it's also seen a higher proportion of intentionally set fires that the fire service has been called out for compared to the other tips sited further away. There are also more tangible signs of the tip's industrial past and ongoing monitoring than the other, more naturalised tips. If the priority was to remediate the coal tips, this tip would be prioritised. Instead, this tip has been excluded from ERI Ltd's proposal to mine coal tips, with the promise to use some of those profits to then flatten the coal tips and remediate the area.
Nature returning and reclaiming tip 90319
Despite the concerns around toxic elements in tip 90319 and the visible industrial heritage of the site, there are signs of nature slowly returning to the area. It's vital that any measures to remediate this coal tip - or any others - in future take full stock of the nature that has regrown. If there are legitimate safety risks, though, this must be prioritised.
